ALL ISLAND REALTY, INC. : Find the perfect Pine Island, Florida home or future home site in Bokeelia, Saint James City, or Matlacha!


Sweetpea Best1.JPG

At Pine Island Homes and Land you can search for all Pine Island, Florida real estate in the local multiple listing service. I am Erika Foye, accredited buyers representative, and real estate broker for All Island Realty, Inc. I specialize in representing buyers of Pine Island, Florida waterfront homes, rural homes, lots, land, condominiums and small farms.

The main communities on Pine Island are:  Bokeelia (north end), Saint James City (sound end), Pine Island Center (center), and Matlacha, the small coastal island that's  drawbridge is the gateway to Pine Island proper.

Let me assist your real estate search!  There are 98 waterfront single family homes, 52 off-water single family homes, 22 condominiums, 45 manufactured homes now listed for sale on Pine Island, along with 85 waterfront lots and 158 off water lots as of Summer, 2014.

A general range of Pine Island real estate presently listed for sale includes:

Island One Half Acre Homesites Starting at $12,900.
Fresh Water Lake and Canal Lots Starting at $25,000.
Golf Course Lots Starting at $39,000.
Salt Water Gulf Access Lots Starting at $85,000.
Agricultural Acres - Starting around $15,000. per acre.

Island Off Water Homes Starting at $89,000.
Golf Course Homes Starting at $209,000.
Salt Water/Gulf Access Homes Starting at $239,000.
Waterfront Condominiums Starting at $165,000.
Homes zoned AG-2 allowing horses $199,000. and up

You can see recent real estate statistics and local events at my blog:   Or search for real estate according to your own criteria at

I have zoning and land use maps for all of Pine Island. As an Accredited Buyers Representative (ABR) I work for and advocate for YOU the buyer!  Also, I am a certified short sale and foreclosure resource, by the National Association of Realtors.

About 480 properties are listed for sale on Pine Island today, about 220 residential and 260 vacant land parcels. As an experienced buyers agent, I can help you find the Pine Island real property with the best location, the amenities you are seeking, at the best price. Bokeelia, St. James City and Matlacha are all unique communities and I'd be glad to tell you more about them. Call  (239-560-8514)or email me at for free maps, a comparative market analysis, more information about the local area, or a complete listing of land and homes available.

Let me help you find out more about Pine Island!  I was glad to be voted "Best Realtor in Customer Service" and named a Gold Star Professional seven of the past eight years by Gulf Shore Life Magazine.   I've also been quoted in national news stories, Coastal Living Magazine, and Where to Retire Magazine. I'm  glad to share what a great place Pine Island is to live! 

If you are looking for a dedicated buyer's representative, I'd be glad to provide you with more information. Sincerely, Erika Foye, Real Estate Broker, All Island Realty, Inc.












Accredited Buyer's Representative ~ Voted "Best Pine Island Realtor", a Four Star Professional Real Estate Agent 7 times in 8 years!

Website Design by Colony One